Another week has gone by, yet we are no further along in the Peyton Manning decision process. Despite numerous reports, Jim Irsay and Peyton Manning have to yet to meet and discuss the franchise quarterback’s future with the Colts. But just because no decisions have been made  doesn’t mean that there’s no news. Some authority figures took to the podium and “answered” some questions, a campaign was started, and fans received several more cryptic messages. Here’s what #ColtsNation had to say this week:

The city of Indianapolis once again took center stage in the football realm when the NFL Combine began on Wednesday at Lucas Oil Stadium. The top football prospects in the nation are currently residing in the Colts’ house, including the two top draft-bound quarterbacks, Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III. While most believe Luck is the superior of the two, each possesses  a unique skill set. Jim Irsay was excited to welcome them.

But, as was the case during Super Bowl week, Peyton Manning became the biggest story of combine week in Indianapolis. Seemingly, each day brought a new angle to his recovery saga. Unfortunately, this issue was not open for discussion for Irsay.

In fact, by the end of the week, Irsay wasn’t even around to speak with Manning. John Clayton reported Thursday that the Colts owner up and left town:

So where is Irsay? Why would he leave when he all but promised he would begin negotiating with Manning this week? Why would he not stay in Indy to observe Andrew Luck, whom the Colts are likely to select with their first overall draft pick? New Colts General Manager Ryan Grigson addressed the media Thursday and announced that, while the Colts have not yet decided whether to release Manning, they also have not decided whether they will draft Luck, something that seemed to be definite a few weeks ago.

So it very well may be that the Colts really aren’t hiding anything; they just don’t know. The Colts’ decision-making may be as certain as the current strength of Peyton Manning’s arm.

But something that may be more certain (and encouraging) is the status of possible free agent Robert Mathis. New Head Coach Chuck Pagano also spoke to the media at the combine and voiced a strong desire to keep both Mathis and Dwight Freeney as staples in his soon-to-be-implemented 3-4 defensive scheme.

According to Pagano, Mathis and Freeney ”are Colts through and through. We fully expect to have them here as long as we can.” I like the sound of that.

So with Manning’s future seemingly up for grabs, another fan base wasted no time in vying for No.18′s attention. In Miami, Dolphins fans did as #BroncoNation did with Tim Tebow and…purchased a billboard.

The “Manning to Miami” campaign has begun. They even have a website where you can sign a petition that will be sent to the Dolphins’ front office. By all means, don’t sign it! Unless Peyton tells you to.

So #ColtsNation, we are still in limbo. And Jim Irsay isn’t willing to offer any answers.

Stay tuned! Remember, for more #Colts news and commentary, you can follow me @catierae08! Check back in with #HorseBytes next week!

I'll always view Peyton as No.1 -- and as No. 18, of course. Mandatory Credit: Matt Stamey-US PRESSWIRE

Decision time is drawing near: Peyton Manning and Jim Irsay plan to meet sometime this week to discuss Manning’s future with the Colts. Public opinion says Manning will be released from the team following his season-long absence while recovering from neck surgery. As a diehard Colts fan, I find myself conflicted. After all, Peyton is who first drew me to the team and to football. How can I cheer for the Colts without him? Here’s what I would love to say to Peyton if I had the chance to talk to him in the coming weeks. If you’re out there No.18, I hope you read this knowing that it comes from the heart.

Read my letter after the jump …

(more…)

Tony Dungy may make it hard for Ryan Grigson to keep Jim Caldwell around.

New Colts general manager Ryan Grigson has a couple of daunting decisions staring him in the face right off the bat, and that can be a tough row to hoe.   Keep Peyton Manning, draft Andrew Luck, or do both?  Re-sign Robert Mathis or let him walk?   Buy a house in Carmel or in Fishers?  Of course, if there weren’t a lot of tough choices ahead, the GM chair would never have been vacant, and Grigson would be elsewhere.   As it stands, though, his most immediate decision will be what to do with head coach Jim Caldwell.

For his part, Caldwell brings a very milquetoast career record of 26-22 to the table.   That tally was slammed to the floor by this season’s paltry 2-14 showing, and a large part of the blame for that can be laid at the feet of Bill and Chris Polian, who failed to build a roster that could withstand, in any fashion, the loss of Manning.  On the other hand, a healthy portion of the success that Caldwell enjoyed early on in his head coaching career with the Colts can be attributed to successor and mentor Tony Dungy.   Dungy, along with Bill Polian, helped build the team that won a Super Bowl under Dungy and made it to another with Caldwell at the helm.    That 2009 team could have won big for any number of coaches, but Caldwell happened to be on duty that year.

Which way will Grigson go, then?    It seems clear to me that the Colts have committed to cleaning house, and it’s really hard to see how they can follow through on that mission without lopping off the head of the coaching staff.  Of course, the decision on Caldwell will not be Grigson’s alone, because owner Jim Irsay is the final arbiter of what’s right and wrong for the Colts.

My money is on a swift end to Caldwell’s tenure in Indianapolis.   If it happens, I hope that it happens soon enough to get the new man on board in time for the draft and all the zaniness that lies ahead.