Sep 15, 2013; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Indianapolis Colts quarterback Andrew Luck (12) scrambles out of the pocket during the fourth quarter against the Miami Dolphins at Lucas Oil Stadium. The Dolphins won 24-20. Mandatory Credit: Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly: Week 2 Edition

Credit: Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Credit: Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Yesterday, the 1-0 Indianapolis Colts hosted the 1-0 Miami Dolphins in which both teams had high post season aspirations. This is the 2nd time in as many years that the Colts and Dolphins had squared off with the Colts winning their first matchup. This time around however, Miami came into town with a far superior team than their 2012 incarnation due to them making a splash in free agency picking up players such as Mike Wallace, Brent Grimes, and Danelle Ellerbe. The Colts would wind up losing a closely contested game against a team that is very well on the rise in the Miami Dolphins. Andrew Luck again attempted to rally the troops for his 9th comeback victory of his career but fell short.

The Good

  • Indianapolis’ running game didn’t miss a beat even though Vick Ballard went on IR due to tearing his ACL. The Colts ran for 133 yards on 26 carries. The Colts leading rusher was Ahmad Bradshaw who showed signs of his former New York Giants self with 15 carries for 65 yards and a score. He showed no signs of injury to his foot and still has that short burst of speed to make small gains into considerable ones. It’s a step in the right direction for the Colts running game to be putting up these numbers against a team that was known as a run stopper.
  • T.Y Hilton made some incredible plays throughout the game especially when he was defended by Pro Bowler Brent Grimes. His 124 yards on 6 catches were a career best as the Dolphins had no answer for Hilton.
  • Coby Fleener had the best game of his young career. I had said that Coby Fleener was due for a breakout game with Dwayne Allen being injured with a hip injury. It’s good to see Fleener have this big of a game as his career up to this point had been anything but great. If Fleener continues to improve,  Andrew Luck will then have two reliable options in the tight end position.
  • The Colts sacked Ryan Tannehill four times and forced a fumble in the process. It was a breath of fresh air to see the Colts get to the quarterback for a change versus what we saw last week against Oakland. However, stat padding was only a smokescreen because….

The Bad

  • … Other than those four sacks, the Colts could not get a consistent pass rush on Ryan Tannehill as he stayed in the pocket and picked the Colts apart. It’s very difficult to win a football game when the opposing quarterback goes 23/34 for 319 and a TD. Other than Tannehill’s fumble, he made passes with precision and poise on a consistent level throughout the game.
  • The offensive line allowed three sacks, which was better than last week’s four, but gave up two sacks during the potential comeback drive late in the first quarter. In the 4th quarter, there were numerous times the pocket collapsed in which Luck had to scramble for some yardage. However, the bad outweighed the good as on 4th down, Luck was sacked on the Miami 23. This is the first time I could think of that Luck got sacked during a potential 4th quarter comeback drive.
  • There was no answer to Mike Wallace as he had his best game as a Miami Dolphin with 9 receptions for 115 yards and a TD. Greg Toler was matched up with him most of the game but couldn’t stop him.
  • Andrew Luck wasn’t at the top of his game yesterday. Several passes he made were very likely to be intercepted but the Dolphins defensive players were unable to catch them. Luck also threw a late game interception in the endzone to Brent Grimes which was intended for Reggie Wayne. It seemed more of a desperation attempt as Brent Grimes was all over Reggie and picked the ball off with ease.

The Ugly

  • Donald Thomas left the game in the first quarter due to a quadriceps injury which turned out to be a torn quad. He will be out for the season and 2nd round pick Hugh Thornton will take over left guard duties.
  • Darrius Heyward-Bey suffered injuries to his ribs and should be undergoing an MRI sometime this week.
  • After Ryan Tannehill’s fumble in the beginning of the third quarter. The Colts drove down the field throwing two passes to TE Dominique Jones. After the second catch, Luck ran it into the endzone on a QB sneak. However, the Dolphins challenged the second catch and it was rules that it was in fact, not a catch. The Colts on the next play would score a TD via a pass from Luck to Fleener but was again called back due to an illegal shift from the Colts offense. The Colts would settle for a field goal and wouldn’t score again for the remainder of the game. This could have very well ruined the tempo of the offense as they were rolling in the first half after coming back from a 14-3 deficit.

Losses are always difficult to swallow in the NFL, especially losses in close games like this one. Remember, this team is still growing before our very eyes and cannot win every close game that falls onto Andrew Luck’s lap. Sometimes, like today, the magic was just not there. With the talent that Luck has, the magic will be there more times than not.

Things don’t get easier for the Colts because next week, they travel to Candlestick Park to take on the defending NFC Champion San Francisco 49ers. This game should be the game of the week as it is slated to be an afternoon game in which the storyline will be Andrew Luck taking on his former college coach at Stanford, Jim Harbaugh.


Frank McMahen is a Staff Writer at Naptown’s Finest. Follow Frank and Naptown’s Finest on Twitter.

Next Colts Game View full schedule »
Thursday, Aug 2828 Aug7:00at Cincinnati BengalsBuy Tickets

Tags: Indianapolis Colts

  • Matt

    Hey Frank, Dolphin fan here. I’d just like your take on the Ryan Tannehill. I know this is pretty outlandish to say but let’s pretend Andrew Luck never existed for a second. Would you feel better having Tannehill vs the other young QB’s in the league? What I’m really asking is other Andrew Luck who would you feel most comfortable being the starter for the Colt’s.

    • Frank McMahen

      There’s a funny story about Tannehill. I went to college at Texas Tech and when A&M came to town in 2009, I believe he was playing wide receiver. Two years later, he played quarterback and won a close one in Lubbock against us. Him, like Gabbert, Bradford and Weeden who I also saw play will always be intertwined with me. I liked his poise in college and I like it even more now.

      I’d take Tannehill over any quarterback drafted since 2010 any day. I’m not high on Bradford due to injury history. I’m not a fan of the mobile quarterbacks like Cam, Kaepernick, Wilson, and Griffin III as they could get hurt easily and run a very hokey, gimmicky offense that I am not a fan of. Dalton is real finicky to me and I don’t really trust him to win those big games. Locker, Gabbert and Ponder just arn’t very good to me and would be more of a detriment.

      I’d be comfortable totally with Tannehill just because I see the willingness to grow and learn to be a pocket passer. I like those kind of players that shun commercial deals, popularity in order to better their skill set. I think he could very well turn the corner with the type of offense he has as well as a strong defense. It could very well be his division when Brady retires or even if the Patriots managed to fall apart offensively this year.

      • Matt

        I saw that you went to Texas Tech. Why I figured I would ask you this question first. We got the same taste in QBs. I’ll take a pocket passer with some speed vs a (do it myself) versatile QB’s. Leave the rushing to the RB’s. I also like the fact that he’s flying under the radar and not making any giant commercial deals and focusing on improving his game

        • Frank McMahen

          For sure. You should be pretty happy that you got a good QB on your hands and things are looking very bright on the horizon. What intrigues me is that what if Cleveland in that draft had drafted Ryan Tannehill with their third pick and Doug Martin with their late 1st round pick. Do you think the Dolphins would have taken Brandon Weeden? And if so, do you think he would have had better success in Miami than he is right now in Cleveland?