Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

Was Andrew Luck Robbed of Rookie of the Year?

The 2012-13 NFL season brought about one of the most impressive classes of rookies quarterbacks in pro football history. With those record-breaking rookies putting their respective teams back on the map, it made the Rookie of the Year choice that much more difficult to decide. With all the successes of the top-three rookie quarterbacks in the league, also came a closely-contested race for which one of these young signal callers would be honored as the best in the league.

Robert Griffin III, Andrew Luck, and Russell Wilson became the first triad of rookies quarterbacks to all lead their teams to the NFL Playoffs in their first season. Wilson was the only one of the three to win a postseason game this year, but all three rookies had amazing statistics, and helped their teams improve in impressive fashion. In the end, Griffin went away with the award, but it could have easily went to either Wilson or Luck.

Andrew Luck not only took over the worst team in the league from the 2011-12 season, he was also asked to do more than the other two Rookie of the Year contending quarterbacks. Luck’s 18 interceptions were the most out of the three, but part of that was due to how much he had to throw the ball. Luck’s 4,374 passing yards were a rookie record, and his 433 yards in week 9 were also a record. His 23 passing touchdowns and five rushing touchdowns were both rookie records for his team.

Not only did Andrew Luck help lead his team to an 11-5 record, but the nine-game win increase was one of the best single-season turnarounds in NFL history. All of the success came from Luck having to fill the shoes of Peyton Manning, as well as taking this Indianapolis franchise back to prominence. Robert Griffin III may have won the Rookie of the Year title for this season, but Andrew Luck certainly did nothing to lose it.


Next Colts Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep6:30at Denver BroncosBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Andrew Luck Indianapolis Colts NFL Robert Griffin Iii

  • guest

    Actually I saw in an article that Luck threw the ball deep over 100 times which was first in the league and had the best completion percentage (accuracy) when throwing the deep ball. So you are right that he had to do more.

  • Dean Caudill

    Damn straight he was ripped. All the guy didn’t do was walk on water. Griffin went to a team that was pretty much on it’s way with the exception of a capable QB. Why did Luck have to throw deep over 100 times? Because he had nothing else to go with and was still sacked over 40 times doing it and still managed to come out of it uninjured. If he had sucked, like what was predicted and expected, there would of been an endless array of people taking a bow while saying “i told you so.”

  • J.M. Nicholas

    There are many factors concerning who gets the awards and how…personally, i believe that Luck’s numerous interceptions cost him Rookie of the Year…but as you have said, if he wasnt put in the position to throw as much as he did, then he wouldnt have had so many turnovers…still, numbers are numbers, and wins are wins…it may have not been flashy, but this guy turned around a terrible team in one season, with a performance unlike anything we’ve really ever seen…thanks for the comments and opinions